To me the photos of Patrick and Terry typically showed a crawly creature that I would expect given the theme and therefore were my #1 and #2. I gave the edge to Patrick, since his photo was just a bit better from a technical perspective. I added Jeff to third place, like Levina, because it was another viewpoint of the theme, but fitted the theme.
The photo of Rosalie was totally unclear for me, which I now better understand given her post on what she did to it. Levina's photo just suited the theme less than the other photos (in my opinion). I did not looked into it very detailed, just viewed it scrolling though the thread, so I did not notice it was heavily post-processed.